Indian Railway Codes and Manuals-Engineering code-Chapter- 2 (II)
MODES OF
INVESTIGATION OF RAILWAY PROJECTS
201. Project Development Process. The Project Development Process consists of the following
sequences :
·
(i) Assessment of
future needs/requirements;
·
(ii) Project
formulation, which is to determine the various options to meet the demand;
·
(iii) Project
investigation which is to examine some selected alternatives as defined in the
terms of reference to the Project Investigator and preparation of Techno
Economic Survey Reports (cf. Para 203) or Feasibility Reports (cf. Para 202) as
the case may be;
·
(iv) Project
evaluation which may involve economic analysis, (cf. Para 235-F) or Social
Profitability Analysis, in addition to financial appraisal;
·
(v) Selection of a
scheme based on such an appraisal; &
·
(vi) Further detailed
examination of the selected scheme by conducting a Preliminary survey (cf. Para
204) wherever necessary for accurate costing and preparation of projects
reports (cf. Para 502) and investment decisions.
202. Project formulation is an essential part of the planning
process and the Project Investigator must be given clear indications regarding
the objectives to be achieved and the options to be investigated. Preinvestment
decision investigations may relate to long term planning and to decide priorities.
Such investigations are in the form of Reconnaissance Surveys (cf. Para 204)
where much detailed investigations are not carried out and cost estimation will
also be approximate. Investigations of this nature are termed "Feasibility
Studies".
203. Techno-Economic
Surveys. Pre-investment decision
investigations may also involve examination of various alternatives including
optimisation of existing facilities to decide the best alternative from
financial and operating point of view to make an ideal investment decision.
Such investigations relating to new lines, doublings, gauge, conversions
schemes, yard remodellings, passenger terminal etc. involving Preliminary
Engineering-cum-Traffic Surveys, (cf Para 204) are termed as Techno-Economic,
Surveys. In these surveys, data, regarding the growth of traffic is collected,
traffic projections are made the existing facilities are evaluated the
possibility of optimising them and new alternative schemes are examined. An
estimate prepared based on such an investigation should under ordinary
circumstances be sufficiently accurate to permit investment decision
being taken."
204. Classification of Surveys. The various kinds of Surveys which are carried out as a
part of investigation of Railway projects are indicated below :
(i) Traffic Surveys. This is a
detailed study to make a forecast of the traffic prospects to facilitate the
projection of the most promising route and the category of line (cf. Para 210
and 211) to be constructed in the case of new lines and to assess the quantum
of traffic to determine the traffic facilities to be provided on an existing
line. These surveys are to be under-taken in conjunction with Reconnaissance or
Preliminary Engineering surveys so that the Technical feasibility and costs of
the alternative proposals can be taken into account while formulating the
recommendations.
(ii) Reconnaissance
Survey:
·
(a) This term should
apply to all rough and rapid investigations of an area with a view to determine
the technical feasibility and approximate cost of one or more routes for a
projected Railway line from a general examination with the help of contoured
Survey of India maps and other available material without a more careful
investigation of the field and with the use of only those instruments that will
repidly give approximate distances and heights such as prismatic compass,
clinometer and similar instruments.
·
(b) Where suitable
aerial Photographs are available, field investigations by instruments can be
considerably avoided/dispensed with by Steroscopic studies of the Photographs
and site inspections as may be required.
(iii) Preliminary Survey:
·
(a) This consists of a
detailed instrumental examination of the rout / or routes selected as a result
of "Reconnaissance" in order to obtain a close estimate of the
probable cost of the projected line, under this survey. However, staking out of
the alignment with a theodolite is not required. Whether a line is to be built
or not will usually be decided on the result of the survey considered in
conjunction with Traffic survey. The Railway Board may, however, require the
submission of an estimate based on Final Location Survey before sanctioning the
commencement of construction.
·
(b) Whether suitable
aerial photographs are available, detailed instrumental examinations of the
route/ routes selected as a result of "Reconnaissance Survey" could
be considerably avoided dispensed with by using photogrammetric methods which
involve plotting of contoured strip maps.
From aerial Photographs on 1: 10,000 scale or 5 times the
scale of the available photographs for obtaining an optimum alignment.
(iv) A Final
Location Survey will generally be a post investment decision investigation to
prepare working details and to make accurate costing in certain cases. The
principal differences between the work required in a Final Location Survey and
that in a Preliminary Survey is that the alignment finally selected during a
survey should be fully staked on the ground with a theodolite and/or Electronic
Distance Measuring Instruments, the report should be
fuller and detailed plans and sections should be submitted.
205. Decision
to Undertake Survey.-Railway
Administration have no power to undertake Surveys on their own. After a Survey
is included in the sanctioned Budget the General Managers can sanction Survey
Estimates costing upto Rs. 3 lakhs.
206.
Preliminary Investigation.-In the case of
construction of new lines a preliminary investigation should be undertaken by
the Railway Administration concerned to determine how the proposed line will
fit in with the general scheme of future railway development. The preliminary
investigation should be based on a careful study of information already
available from existing maps, published figures of trade and population of the
area to be served and financial and statistical data of existing railways in
similar country.
207. Form the
results of this investigation it should be possible for the Railway
Administration to decide the surveys (see para 204) to be undertaken and take a
preliminary view of the category of line (see para 210 & 211) to be
provided.
208. If it is
decided to undertake a Survey in connection with any proposal for the
construction of a new line, additional lines and gauge conversion, estimate for
the proposed Survey should be prepared. In the case of Surveys for new lines,
the information collected in the course of Preliminary Investigation (vide para
206) should be embodied in the report accompanying the estimate.
209. Terms of
Reference.-The project Investigator should
be supplied by the Railway Administration with terms of reference, and should
indicate the category of line, ruling gradient to be adopted etc. The terms of
reference should include instructions regarding the scope and nature of the
investigations to be carried out, particulars of any railway lines already
projected in the area and what undertakings or interests, if any, are involved
in the proposal. The terms of reference should also include instructions to the
officer-in-charge of the survey to visit the headquarters of the Railway
Administration at suitable intervals both during the progress of work in the
field and during the period of recess in order to consult the General Manager
and his principal officers and where necessary have the original terms of
reference modified from time to time.
210. Categories of Lines.-Broad Gauge lines on Indian Railways are classified into various
categories indicated below, on the basis of future maximum permissible speed.
(1) Group `A'-For a sanctioned speed of 160 km. per hour
·
The minimum rail
section to be adopted will be 60 Kg. in section having traffic density of over
20 GMT and 52 Kgs in other sections.
·
The minimum sleeper
density shall be 1,660 numbers per Km.
·
The ballast cushion
shall be 30 cm.
Bridges will be built to revised BG loading of 1975 with a
maximum axle load of 22.5 tonnes for the locomotive and train load of 7.67
tonnes per meter behind the locomotives with a maximum axle load of 22.9 tonnes
for the train load.
(2) Group `B'-For a sanctioned speed of 130 km. per hour
·
The minimum rail
section to be adopted will be 60 Kg. in sections having traffic density of over
20 GMT and 52 Kg. in other sections.
·
The minimum sleeper
density shall be M+7.
·
The ballast cushion shall
be 25 cm.
Bridges will be built to revised BG loading of 1975 with a
maximum axle load of 22.5 tonnes for the locomotive and a train load of 7.67
tonnes per metre behind the locomotives with a maximum axle load of 22.9 tonnes
for the train load.
(3) Group `C'-Suburban Sections.
·
The minimum rail
section to be adopted will be 60 Kg. in sections having traffic density of over
20 GMT and 52 Kg. in other sections.
·
The minimum sleeper
density shall be M + 7.
·
The ballast cushion
shall be 25 cm.
Bridges will be built to revised BG loading of 1975 with a
maximum axle load of 22.5 tonnes and a train load of 7.67 tonnes per metre
behind the locomotives with a maximum axle load of 22.9 tonnes for the train
load.
(4) Group `D'-Where the maximum sanctioned speed is 100
Kms/hour, as at present.
·
The minimum rail
section to be adopted will be 60 Kg in sections having traffic density of over
20 GMT, 52 Kg. in sections having traffic density from 10 to 20 GMT and 44.5 Kg
in sections having traffic density of less than 10 GMT.
·
The minimum sleeper
density shall be M + 7 in sections having traffic density above 10 GMT and M +
4 in sections having traffic density below 10 GMT.
·
The ballast cushion
shall be 20 cm.
Bridges shall be built to revised BG loading of 1975 with a
maximum axle load of 22.5 tonnes for the locomotive and a train load of 7.67
tonnes per metre behind the locomotives with maximum axle load of 22.9 tonnes
for train load.
(5) Group `E'-Other sections of branch lines with present
sanctioned speed.
·
The minimum rail
section to be adopted will be 60 Kg in section having traffic density of over
20 GMT, 52 Kg in sections having traffic density from 10 to 20 GMT and 44.5 Kg
in sections having traffic density of less than 10 GMT.
·
The minimum sleeper
density shall be M + 4. However, depending on local conditions a density higher
than M + 4 can be adopted where traffic density is 10 GMT and above subject to
Railway Board approval.
·
The ballast cushion
shall be 15 cms.
Bridges will be built to revised BG loading of 1975 with a
maximum axle load of 22.5 tonnes for the locomotives and a train load of 7.67
tonnes per metre behind the locomotives with a maximum axle load of 22.9 tonnes
for the train load.
211. Meter guage
lines on Indian Railways is classified into various categories indicated below
:
(1) Trunk
Routes.- Having a traffic density of 5 million G. T. Km per Km
per annum and above or where the speed will be above 70 Km hour (45 mph).
·
The rail section to be
adopted shall be 37 Kgs (75 lbs.)
·
The sleeper density
shall be M + 7.
·
The ballast cushion
shall be 25 cms.
Bridges will be built to MGML standard of loading i. e.
13.2 tonnes axle loads and a train of 3.87 tonnes per metre run behind the
engine.
(2) Main lines
(other than trunk routes). - Having a traffic density of 2.5 to 5.0 million
G. T. Km per Km per annum.
·
The rail section to be
adopted shall be 30 Kg.
·
The sleeper density
shall be M + 7.
·
The ballast cushion
shall be 20 cms.
Bridge will be built to MGML standard of loading i. e. 13.2
tonnes axle load and a train of 3.87 tonnes per metre run behind the engine.
(3) Other main
lines and branch lines. Having a
traffic density of 1.25 to 2.5 million G. T. Km per Km per annum.
·
The rail section shall
be 30 Kg.
·
The sleeper density
shall be M + 4.
·
The ballast cushion
shall be 20 cms.
Bridges will be built to MGML standard of loading i. e.
13.2 tonnes axle loads and a train of 3.87 tonnes per metre run behind the
engine.
(4) Tertiary
lines. Having a traffic density of
below 1.25 million G. T. Km per Km per annum.
·
The rail section to be
adopted shall be 30 Kg (normally released second-handrail).
·
The minimum sleeper
density shall be M + 2.
Bridges will be built to MGBL standard of loading i. e.
10.7 tonnes axle loads and a train of 3.87 tonnes per metre run behind the
engine.
212. The use of
second-hand rails is permissible, provided that they have not lost more than
ten per cent of their weight and, having regard to the volume of traffic
expected, that their anticipated life in the new line is not less than ten
years.
213. Railway
Administrations may decide, on the merits of each particular case, the standard
of ballasting necessary on first opening.
Multiple choice questions:
1. What is the first step in the
Project Development Process for railway projects?
a) Project formulation
b) Project evaluation
c) Assessment of future needs/requirements
d) Project investigation
Answer: c) Assessment of future
needs/requirements
2. What is involved in the Project
formulation stage?
a) Detailed examination of the
selected scheme
b) Economic analysis and social profitability analysis
c) Determining various options to meet the demand
d) Preparation of Techno Economic Survey Reports
Answer: c) Determining various
options to meet the demand
3. What type of surveys are
conducted to examine selected alternatives and prepare Techno Economic Survey
Reports or Feasibility Reports?
a) Traffic Surveys
b) Preliminary Surveys
c) Reconnaissance Surveys
d) Project investigation surveys
Answer: d) Project investigation
surveys
4. What is a Reconnaissance Survey
primarily used for in railway project investigations?
a) Detailed instrumental examination
of the route
b) Determining the technical feasibility and approximate cost
c) Preparing working details and accurate costing
d) Economic analysis and social profitability analysis
Answer: b) Determining the technical
feasibility and approximate cost
5. In which type of survey is the
alignment staked out on the ground with a theodolite and/or Electronic Distance
Measuring Instruments?
a) Traffic Survey
b) Reconnaissance Survey
c) Preliminary Survey
d) Final Location Survey
Answer: d) Final Location Survey
6. Which category of lines on Indian
Railways has a sanctioned speed of 160 km/h?
a) Group A
b) Group B
c) Group C
d) Group D
Answer: a) Group A
7. What is the minimum sleeper
density required for Group A lines?
a) M + 4
b) M + 7
c) 1,660 numbers per Km
d) 1,200 numbers per Km
Answer: c) 1,660 numbers per Km
8. For which type of lines is the
ballast cushion required to be 30 cm?
a) Group A
b) Group B
c) Group C
d) Group D
Answer: a) Group A
9. Which of the following statements
is true for Group B lines?
a) They have a maximum sanctioned
speed of 100 km/h.
b) The minimum rail section is 44.5 kg.
c) The ballast cushion is 25 cm.
d) They require a sleeper density of M + 4.
Answer: c) The ballast cushion is 25
cm.
10. What is the maximum axle load
for trains on Group D lines?
a) 22.5 tonnes
b) 22.9 tonnes
c) 20 tonnes
d) 19.5 tonnes
Answer: b) 22.9 tonnes
11. What type of survey should be
conducted if a project needs to determine how a proposed line will fit with
future railway development?
a) Traffic Survey
b) Reconnaissance Survey
c) Preliminary Investigation
d) Final Location Survey
Answer: c) Preliminary Investigation
12. Which category of meter gauge
lines has the highest traffic density?
a) Trunk Routes
b) Main lines (other than trunk routes)
c) Other main lines and branch lines
d) Tertiary lines
Answer: a) Trunk Routes
13. For meter gauge lines, what is
the minimum rail section used on trunk routes?
a) 30 kg
b) 37 kg
c) 44.5 kg
d) 52 kg
Answer: b) 37 kg
14. On tertiary lines with meter
gauge, what is the standard of loading for bridges?
a) MGML standard of loading
b) MGBL standard of loading
c) BGML standard of loading
d) MGML and MGBL standards are the same
Answer: b) MGBL standard of loading
15. What is a key criterion for the
use of second-hand rails on new lines?
a) The rails must not have lost more
than 5% of their weight.
b) The anticipated life in the new line must be at least five years.
c) The anticipated life in the new line must be at least ten years.
d) The rails must be at least 60 kg in weight.
Answer: c) The anticipated life in
the new line must be at least ten years.
******
Comments
Post a Comment