Indian Railway Codes and Manuals-Administration and Finance-Chapter-11 (XI)
CHAPTER
XI
DISALLOWANCES
AND OBJECTIONS
Disallowances of Personal Claims:
1101. Claims which are not susceptible of internal
check will be returned by the Accounts Officer to the officer
submitting them for amendment or explanation.
1102. Claims which are susceptible of internal check,
though incorrect otherwise, will be passed by the Accounts
Officer for the correct amount, the amount not admitted being
disallowed. The amount of disallowance and the
reasons therefore should be intimated to the officer drawing the bill, with the
least possible delay, for communication to the person concerned. When the
sanction of a higher authority is necessary to the payment of an amount
disallowed, it shall be duty of the officer drawing the bill to obtain such
sanction before the amount disallowed is passed for payment.
1103. Provisional payments.—Except in respect of staff
governed by Payment of Wages Act, no provisional
payment shall be made without a request received from the authority competent
finally to sanction the payment and the request should specify a
definite period (not exceeding three months) for which
provisional payments should continue in anticipation of
sanction. This is specially necessary when the
provisional payments is one in favour of the
Paying Officer himself. As
regards the staff governed by Payment of
Wages Act where delay in payment is likely to infringe the
Act, ex-post facto request by the
competent authority should be made at the earliest opportunity if
there is no time for prior request.
Note:-(i) In very emergent circumstances where the G. M.
considers that provisional payment has to be made in the case of -non-gazetted
employee (s), he may, in consultation with his F. A. & C. A. O. direct that
such a payment may be made on the written authority of the gazetted officer
(s), nominated for the purpose, subject to subsequent regularization by the
competent authority in term of the above rule. The Gazetted officer on whose
authority such provisional payment is made, should make an immediate report to
the competent authority for sanction. In the case of monthly recurring
payments, such provisional payments should be restricted to payments for a
month.
(ii) Provisional payment should not be resorted to in cases
in which recoveries may have to be effected and it is foreseen that there may
be obvious difficulty in effecting recoveries later due to complication arising
from the provisions of the Payment of Wages Act, etc.
When Audit object to upgrading of a post, the pay of the
staff concerned should be frozen and no further increments in that scale should
be allowed to them until the Audit objection has been finally disposed of. If
any of the pasts which have bean allotted the higher grade and which have been
objected to by Audit fall vacant subsequently, they should be downgraded in
accordance with the Audit views, and future promotions ordered only in the
lower grade until the matter is settled.
1104. When a claim has been disallowed on the ground
that it is not covered by an existing rule or order and the drawing officer or
the party concerned is unable to accept the
Accounts Officer's interpretation, it shall be op&n to the
drawing officer or the party concerned to represent the case
to a higher authority, end the amount disallowed will not be passed
for payment unless the Accounts Officer's interpretation of the
rule or order is set aside by the authority competent to do so.
1105. Ordinarily all personal claims will be checked
finally within one year of the date of payment, and if within this
period an amount is discovered to have been paid erroneously, through an
oversight in the accounts office and not due to wrong interpretation of a rule
or order, it will ordinarily be recovered: When the amount so
detected can, without hardship to the party concerned, be recovered from a
current bill the recovery will be made by the Accounts Officer from such
bill. If, however, the amount discovered to have been erroneously paid
cannot be met from the amount payable in the current bill
or is so large as compared with the person's pay that its recovery
is, in the opinion of the Financial Advisor and Chief Accounts Officer, likely
to cause a hardship to the party concerned, the amount will be held under
objection and the drawing officer requested to take steps to recover the amount
from the next bill or to obtain the sanction of the Head of Department,
Additional/ Deputy Heads of Departments,
Divisional Superintendents,
Deputy Chief Mechanical Engineers
or Works Managers in indep3ndent charge of Workshops, as the case may be, the
recovery being made in a suitable number of installments.
1106. When erroneous payments have been passed for
considerable time owing to a wrong interpretation of a financial rule or order,
the new interpretation will be given effect from the date which the competent
authority may decide when giving the correct interpretation. If no date is specifically
fixed, the correct interpretation will be given effect from the date of issue
of the competent authority's orders stating the correct interpretation.
1107. If any payments have to be disallowed more than one
year after the date on which they were made, the amount of overpayment will be
held under objection and reported to the head of the department for orders
whether the recovery should be enforced or waived. All possible action should
be taken in order to recover quickly any overpayments made and no recoverable
overpayment should be ordinarily waived but where these are waived, there
should be fullest justification for such waiver.
1108. Every railway officer should
attend promptly to any objection communicated to him by the
Account-Officer and all objections relating to personal claims
raised by the Accounts Officers or by the Audit Department, whether accepted or
not, should immediately be communicated to the parties concerned, so
that the question of write-off of the amounts in the ground that they are more
than a year old may not arise, in case it is eventually decided that the
objections are correct and the amounts disallowed are to be recovered.
1109. The Railway Board have full powers to
sanction the write-off of amounts overdrawn by Railway
servants or otherwise due from them. The
General Managers may exercise the power of the Railway
Board under this paragraph in respect of non-gazetted staff. In
the case of Gazetted officers, the General Managers may waive
recovery of amounts overdrawn by them or otherwise due from them, if the
erroneous payment or the amount due is discovered by Accounts or
Audit more than one year after the date on which it was made
or on which it was due. The General Manager may redelegate his
powers under this paragraph to any authority subordinate to him, subject to
such conditions as he may deem fit to prescribe.
Note.—In cases where an amount due from a person has to be
written off on the ground that he/she is no longer in railway service and no
recovery is, therefore, possible the orders sanctioning write-off should
invariably contain a clause that any sums which are subsequently found due to
the person concerned will be adjusted against the amount written.
1110. The power to remit a disallowance,
vide paragraph 1109,
is exerciseable only if the amount disallowed, having
been finally passed by the Accounts Officer had been drawn by the railway
servant concerned under the reasonable belief that he was entitled to it.
1111. The circumstances in which
the Accounts Officers may waive objections on their
own authority have been described in the Indian Railway Code for the
Accounts Department.
Objections relating to Other Claims:
1112. An item of expenditure may be held under
objection for one more of the allowing reasons, viz. :—
(i) Want of sanctioned estimate ;
(ii) Excess over sanctioned estimate ;
(iii) Want of sanctioned appropriation ;
(iv) Excess over sanctioned appropriation ; and
(v) Miscellaneous reasons, e. g., absence of vouchers,
breach of a financial rule, incorrect allocation, etc.
1113. It is the duty of the Accounts
Officer to bring to the notice of the executive authority
concerned without any avoidable delay, all items of irregular
expenditure held under objection by him and it shall be the function
of the executive authority to take the earliest possible steps for the
regularization of the expenditure by according of obtaining the necessary
sanction, or by ordering recovery of the amount irregularly disbursed or by
furnishing the further information required by the Accounts Officer.
1114. If the executive authority concerned is unable
to accept the objection raised by the Accounts Officer, it should at once refer
the matter to the next higher authority for his orders and
the objection shall not be considered as having been
cleared until it has been either withdrawn by the
Accounts Officer or over-ruled by the competent authority.
1115. When
a Financial Adviser and Chief Accounts Officer considers that the action taken
by the administration in a particular case is inadequate, he will ask the
General- Manager to report the matter to the Railway Board for orders,
furnishing him at the same time, for transmission to the Railway
Board, a statement of the reasons for which he considers such
action imperative. The orders of the Railway Board on such a
reference, when received by the General Manager, shall be furnished by him to
the Financial Adviser and Chief Accounts Officer
(vide paragraph 108-A I)
Multiple choice questions:
What action should the Accounts
Officer take if a claim is not susceptible to internal check?
A. Pass it for the correct amount
B. Return it to the officer submitting it for amendment or explanation
C. Disallow it immediately
D. Forward it to the Railway Board
Answer: B. Return it to the officer submitting it for amendment or
explanation
2. If a claim is susceptible to
internal check but is incorrect otherwise, what should the Accounts Officer do?
A. Disallow the entire claim
B. Return the claim for correction
C. Pass it for the correct amount and disallow the incorrect part
D. Approve the claim provisionally
Answer: C. Pass it for the correct amount and disallow the
incorrect part
3. Under what condition can
provisional payments be made without prior request for staff governed by the
Payment of Wages Act?
A. When the General Manager directs
it
B. When there is an ex-post facto request from the competent authority
C. When the Accounts Officer approves
D. When the claim is below a certain amount
Answer: B. When there is an ex-post facto request from the
competent authority
4. Who has the authority to direct
provisional payments in emergent circumstances for non-gazetted employees?
A. Financial Adviser and Chief
Accounts Officer
B. General Manager
C. Chief Commercial Superintendents
D. Railway Board
Answer: B. General Manager
5. What should be done when an
erroneous payment is discovered within one year of the date of payment?
A. Write off the amount
B. Recover it from the current bill if possible
C. Forward the case to the Railway Board
D. Issue a warning to the drawing officer
Answer: B. Recover it from the current bill if possible
6. Who is responsible for recovering
amounts erroneously paid if they cannot be met from the current bill and are
too large to be recovered without causing hardship?
A. General Manager
B. Accounts Officer
C. Financial Adviser and Chief Accounts Officer
D. Head of Department
Answer: D. Head of Department
7. What should happen when a claim
is disallowed because it is not covered by an existing rule or order, and the
drawing officer disagrees with the Accounts Officer's interpretation?
A. The claim is automatically
approved
B. The drawing officer or the party concerned can represent the case to a
higher authority
C. The claim is forwarded to the Railway Board
D. The Accounts Officer's decision is final
Answer: B. The drawing officer or the party concerned can represent
the case to a higher authority
8. What should be done with payments
disallowed more than one year after they were made?
A. They should be recovered
immediately
B. They should be reported to the head of the department for orders on recovery
or waiver
C. They should be written off
D. They should be ignored
Answer: B. They should be reported to the head of the department
for orders on recovery or waiver
9. Who has the full powers to
sanction the write-off of amounts overdrawn by Railway servants?
A. Financial Adviser and Chief
Accounts Officer
B. General Manager
C. Railway Board
D. Chief Commercial Superintendents
Answer: C. Railway Board
10. Who may exercise the power to
waive the recovery of overdrawn amounts for non-gazetted staff?
A. General Manager
B. Accounts Officer
C. Financial Adviser and Chief Accounts Officer
D. Railway Board
Answer: A. General Manager
11. What is the duty of the
executive authority when an item of irregular expenditure is held under
objection by the Accounts Officer?
A. Ignore the objection
B. Refer the matter to the Railway Board
C. Take steps for regularization or recovery
D. Approve the expenditure provisionally
Answer: C. Take steps for regularization or recovery
12. What should be done if the
executive authority is unable to accept the objection raised by the Accounts
Officer?
A. Ignore the objection
B. Forward the matter to the next higher authority
C. Pass the claim provisionally
D. Write off the objection
Answer: B. Forward the matter to the next higher authority
Comments
Post a Comment